Last updated 2013 October 17 09:05 UT
This post will be added to as time and information permits.
|The Claim||The Reality|
|McTaggart (said) her journal would accept no advertising - "we have to remain pure" -||Not only is approximately a quarter of each issue devoted to advertising (based on June 2013 issue), in February 2013, the Nightingale Collaboration reported that the Advertising Standards Authority had adjudicated against advertising in WDDTY to the tune of 54 CAP-Code breaches. This is in addition to eleven "informally resolved" cases (i.e. the advertising was acknowledged to be in breach of CAP-Codes and was amended voluntarily.)|
|"...the Nightingale Collaboration, a ragtag group who meet in a pub of the same name..."||Errr.. there is no pub called The Nightingale Collaboration.|
|"...the pharmaceutically backed organization [Simon Singh] fronts, 'Sense About Science'...."||Sense About Science is a charity. Its accounts are therefore open to scrutiny.
Less than 5% of its funding comes from companies; none of these is a pharmaceutical company.
|WDDTY complained: "The Times stated: we said vitamin C cures HIV."|
|"Five Live followed up with a television debate about our magazine."||Five Live doesn't do TV debates. (Clue: It is a radio station!)|
|"It's also apparent from the information published in The Times and in all the media following that not one journalist or broadcaster has read one single word we've written, particularly on the homeopathy story, and for very good reason: the article and the magazine containing it in fact have not yet been published."||Ummm -- WDDTY published their claims for homeopathy months ago!
And bragged on Facebook about doing so!
|(To the Times)
"You have no idea yet what we're going to write about, so how can you say we're going to write that homeopathy 'cures' cancer?"
|Ummm... Maybe they were referring to a claim WDDTY has already made? (See above)
|"Just to clarify yet another lie about us: we are not 'pro' or 'anti' vaccine."||From WDDTY, June 2013: "The safest interpretation is that the MMR increases the risk of autism by 5 per cent"
|"Not one of the newspapers, radio shows or television stations bothered to contact us, even to solicit a comment,,,"||The Times journalist who reported on the campaign to get the magazine off supermarket shelves sent this email:
And phoned twice:
(Having had no reply from the "Editorial" department, he next tried "Accounts and General Management")
|"...the Swiss government decided that there is some proof of homeopathy..."||It did nothing of the sort! See Zeno's Blog for what really happened.|
|"For months, Singh, whose Sense About Science group has the sponsorship of the British Pharmaceutical Association..."||If the The British Pharmaceutical Association actually exists and is not just something else made up by McTaggart, it is not a sponsor of Sense About Science.|
|"[Waitrose] are not one of our stockists"||Curious. That's not what the distributor thinks:
|"The letter being sent out by the Times to our readers..."||The Times is sending out letters to WDDTY readers?
Is WDDTY implying that the Times somehow get hold of the WDDTY subscriber database?
Has anyone ever actually seen one of these letters?
What does become apparent is that WDDTY needs some sort of disclaimer on a lot of what it asserts!